Mushrooms are one of the most perfect ingredients for minimalist, less is more cooking, and these simple roasted hen of the woods / maitake are a great example. Sure, you can make them into pasta sauce, jerky, and all kinds of things, but probably the simplest, and one of the most delicious things to make, is simply to roast them, and eat them fresh from the oven, with you’re hunting buddy, and a cold drink, far away from mosquitos and horseflies.
There’s a couple things to mention, mainly that you should imprint the word “roasted” as opposed to “baked” in the recipe here. Roasting means we’re going to use relatively high heat. I say 425F in the recipe below, but simple recipes relying on only a few high quality ingredients can be fussy, so know that you may have to up the heat a bit at the end, or reduce it a little to get crisp edges depending on how well your oven is calibrated. Use your instincts, but absolutely do not overcrowd the pan since the maitake won’t roast properly, and will end up steaming.
My first hen of 2019 went straight from the stump to it’s new home: the oven.
When properly done, you should end up with roasted hen niblets, perfect for snacking on with a drink, with slightly herbed, crisp edges, but a slightly chewy, tender center. As the mushrooms cool on the baking sheet, they’ll continue to cook, and crisp a bit, so don’t worry if your’s aren’t how you envision them immediately after you take them from the oven.
Dark with mahogany edges is what you’re looking for here.
You’ll be surprised how fast a pound of hen of the woods mushrooms will disappear, and I can just about guarantee that if you have more than a pound in the fridge, you’ll be making more than one tray of maitake. You can make this in larger batches than a pound, too, just use multiple baking sheets, or bake in batches.
They’re best eaten fresh from the oven, still warm.
Roasted Hen of the Woods or Maitake Mushrooms
Ingredients
- 12 Oz hen of the woods Preferably wild, peeled into leaves, cleaned (lightly swished in water and/or brushed as needed if wild/dirty)
- 3 tablespoons flavorless cooking oil
- ¼ teaspoon kosher salt plus an extra sprinkle
- 1 teaspoon Chopped fresh thyme, rosemary, or sage dried thyme is an ok substitute, but not rosemary as it will burn
- 6-7 cracks of the pepper mill or to taste
- 2-3 cloves garlic, peeled and crushed with a knife
Instructions
- Toss the pieces of hen of the woods (press them between paper towels to weep water if you had to rinse them first) with all ingredients.If you have cultivated hen of the woods, do this very gently as most are quite fragile.
- Spread out on a baking sheet lined with parchment or a silicon mat, and bake in a preheated 425 oven for 25-35 minutes (rotating 180 degrees half way through if your oven heats unevenly) until the mushrooms are crisp around the edges, but still slightly tender in the center.
- Cultivated mushrooms may take a bit longer as they typically contain more water. Wild hens, especially those picked in a dry spell, will cook quicker.
- Remove the mushrooms and allow to cool on the baking sheet until you can handle them, then eat.
Bought a gorgeous maitake at our local farmer’s market. The vendor said to “roast” it. Went online for a little more detail and found your site. Followed your recipe and the results were delicious! Will definitely make this again. Thank you!
Glad it worked for you Brenda.
Thanks for your beautiful recipes using hen of the woods, it’s awful easy to suddenly have a WHOLE LOT of it! This is so simple and sounds delicious, a good way to get more hen down my gullet. I might try it with a squirt of lemon, too.
Welcome, and lemon is great here.
Excellent results for my first time cooking Hen of the Woods. I threw in a sprinkle of smoked paprika as well. Delicious and simple.
i see 375 in the comments and 425 in the recipe itself for roasting temp?
A typo. Thanks for catching that. 425 F is what you want.
When you say flavorless cooking oil, does that mean *not* olive oil, or does it mean oil that is not infused with a flavor?
I consider plain olive oil to have some flavor. I plan to make this recipe and I just want to be sure….this is the first time I’ve run across “flavorless cooking oil”. Thanks!
Ilona, you may not have seen it before, but “flavorless” cooking oil is commonly used in culinary parlance. What it means, basically, is use an oil with a high smoke point. Your plain olive oil, as long as it is not extra virgin, will work fine. Extra virgin will probably smoke a bit, but if you cut it with another oil like grapeseed, etc, it can be used for this. Mix the oils 50/50.
Usually that just refers to a more neutral-tasting oil with a high smoke point like canola, vegetable, etc. Olive oil could work in some cases but in general even the non-extra virgin kinds will have too low a smoke point for cooking at 425 degrees and could potentially lend an acrid flavor as well as undesired transformation to trans fats. Olive oil is not generally considered a flavorless oil in the aforementioned parlance, though I guess you could use lighter olive oil in a pinch. Hope that helps!
Fall 2021 on the east coast is damp! Say you find WAY more maitake than you can eat at one time, and you roast some. Other than snacking on them fresh out of the oven (YUMMM!!), any other suggestions for how to use them?
Oh yeah! I used to have my cooks roast them at a lower temp and then we’d hold them for service, warming them up with butter and lemon and putting on cuts of meat, heating them up in broth, or, one of my favorites, adding to salads fresh out the oven with bacon vinaigrette and chopped boiled egg.
Mmm, I think I’m going to try sautéing the rest of mine. We roasted half of it and I was underwhelmed. Maybe I should have been more generous with the oil.
Kathy, there’s a few things to consider here, and I wouldn’t give up on it just yet. If you underseasoned it, didn’t use the herbs, or your oven is not calibrated correctly it could all affect the finished product.
Thanks for this delicious recipe. I found a large Hen yesterday. This is the first recipe I have tried and it is a keeper. We had is with a wild rice mix and it was a perfect meal
Glad it worked for you. Wild rice is the perfect compliment.