I've always loved Halloween, and I usually do something "seasonal" when it comes around. As a disclaimer, I have to tell you that if you're one of my vegetarian or vegan friends, you'll probably want to skip this one. If you eat meat, and you appreciate the interesting odd tidbit, you may find it interesting, as I did.

Pregnant_doe illustration by Xee Reiter — A pregnant doe in a semi urban setting. A custom illustration just for this post by artist Xee Reiter. Also check her out on IG.

Most of you will know that there are a lot of deer in America, and that human-deer conflicts from overpopulation can be an issue in some places. In a way we've created a new, almost perfect habitat for wild creatures to find food. We all know racoons are adept at opening garbage cans. Squirrels love nuts, but also don't mind a slice of old pizza.

Bears (on my mind as I'm getting ready for an off-grid trip into the British Canadian Wilderness as I write this) are well known for being adaptive carnivores. And, as my hosta-growing neighbors can tell you, an urban garden and landscaping is a just a giant, 24-hour salad bambi bar.

Deer in an urban setting by artist Xee Reiter — I love the extra details Xee added to make the image feel like a wooded backyard in town.

I'm not even going to try to tackle arguments for or against urban hunting/culling, overpopulation, or the destruction that deer can rue unchecked on local ecology (the more pressing discussion as opposed to ethics, in my mind).

Those arguments are far too deep, sprawling, and often too opaque to cover in 1000 words or so. I do believe that the actions of man have made it so that the population needs to be kept in check, but what the most efficient and humane way to go about that is a gladiatorial arena of opinions and emotions for some.

The reality is that plenty of urban areas have deer culls, and will continue to for the foreseeable future (one location I reference used their cull to donate 8,600 pounds of venison to food shelves-a good byproduct I think). What I'm talking about today involves something much more focused on the meat of deer itself, and the timeline at which they're harvested.

Edible hosta shoots or urui — Hosta shoots are one of the preferred urban snacks for deer where I live. I've seen some homeowners get pretty fired up about them.

In Wisconsin and Minnesota, the deer season runs (roughly here, including archery) from late September to mid November. In places where urban deer culls are held, the season may not be in the fall, it might be later in the winter, or nearly spring, or, as in the case of the cull at U-M Dearborn I link to at the end of this post, over Spring break.

Mating season of deer should be around October-Dec. When a hunter harvests a doe, the last thing they probably think about is if she'd been with a buck. If you harvest and butcher one of those does in the spring though, the butchery can be, ahem, more interesting.

So, just so happens I have a friend in Virginia that participates in his local urban deer cull, and it's in the spring. And, for the past few years, the does he's harvested have had some extra baggage in their unborn fetuses. So, he sent me one to cook. Thanks Mark.

I've always been fascinating by the odd, unusual edible, and, I'm also a passionate consumer of offal and organ meats, so, it's honestly right up my alley. What I really wanted to know though, was if there was a tradition of eating unborn animals around the world I could find. Besides a casual Reddit mention, I can't.

Cooking smoked pigeons with young venison for Brunswick stew — To mask the texture, you could cook proto-veal venison in small game stew. I added a couple smoked pigeons for extra meat.

But, humans, enterprising beings that we are, have undoubtedly eaten them, although the only historical anecdote I've come across is Indigenous people cooking buffalo fetus for the elderly who have problems chewing. At the end of the day, meat, is meat.

Unpacking the cooler my friend overnighted me, I found a little vacuum sealed bag with what looked to be a squirrel inside. For all intents and purposes, I'd assume you could cook a small fetus of similar animals of similar size as you would any small game. And small game is exactly what my unborn deer tasted like.

What does it taste like?

Unborn venison or venison fetus — The fetus will need to be gutted like any other animal.

The big question. If you can get past the aversion, which, is, to be blunt, an inculturalized phobia other (non-American) people around the world probably wouldn't have a problem eating, a deer fetus cooks up like a squirrel or other very small game, and tastes like meltingly tender deer veal. I found it mild, extremely tender and pleasant.

Imagine eating the most tender confit you've ever had. It is in no way strong tasting like organ meats or offal. I ate all of it's organs to compare them with other small game, and found them near-identical to rabbit and squirrel offal in taste, which are all mild and delicious. I often compare small game offal to poultry organs (chicken, pigeon etc) as their size and taste is pretty similar.

Other notes

The proto-skin

Everything is mini, and in the process of being formed at this stage, including the skin, which feels a bit like a layer of translucent fat, and, although it won't render out anything noticeable, at least from my experience, seems to really insulate the meat and keep it extremely moist. it was delicious, and seemed to melt into the meat per caul fat.

The tiniest of bones

One hurdle will cooking small game is that the bones can be tiny and hard to keep track of. With rare exception, I do not like bones in my soup and I find it off-putting, as will any average dinner guest.

Cooking a Brunswick stew with smoked pigeons

Adding meat to venison and smoked pigeon Brunswick stew

That being said, as it was the size of a large squirrel, it wasn't going to make a huge meal. With the higher proportion of bones, barbecuing it and slapping it on a bun wasn't going to work, so I turned to a classic small game recipe: the ol' Brunswick stew.

Brunswick stew made from smoked pigeons and young venison — The finished stew.

Brunswick stew is traditionally made with different types of small game, so it worked out just fine. To bulk the meat out I added 2 smoked pigeons from the freezer, rounded it with some of my favorite heirloom tepary beans from Romona Farms.

I also replaced the now common ketchup or barbecue sauce with a dash of birch syrup and some canned tomatoes. It made for one of the most interesting meals of small game I've had to date. If I'll do it again, I don't know.

Print Recipe Pin Recipe

5 from 5 votes

Brunswick Stew with Smoked Pigeon, Young Venison and Tepary Beans

Thick, rich stew made with small game, tepary beans and potatoes, seasoned with birch syrup and herbs. Serves 4 with leftovers

Prep Time1

Cook Time2

Course: Main Course

Cuisine: American

Keyword: Pigeon, Small game

Servings:

Author: Alan Bergo

Ingredients

Stew

2 whole pigeons or a comparable amount of poultry, about 1 pound total
1 unborn venison fetus or 1 lb or bone-in small game, such as a squirrel
2 oz smoked bacon preferably in slab form, diced ¼ inch
5 oz 1 medium onion, diced ½ inch
2 large cloves of garlic minced or grated
1 tablespoon rendered animal fat such as duck or pork
2 teaspoons chopped fresh thyme
2 tablespoons birch syrup
8 oz diced potato rutabaga or turnip
Kosher salt and fresh ground black pepper to taste
1 large can whole peeled tomatoes
½ cup dry white wine
1 cup good strong meat stock

Beans

½ cup dried tepary beans or ¾ cup cooked beans
1 small onion peeled, left whole, and studded with 5 cloves
1 large clove garlic peeled and lightly crushed
1 large dried bay leaf
3 cups water

Serving

Slices of good bread grilled or toasted

Instructions

Pigeon

Season the pigeons all over with salt and pepper and allow to rest for at least an hour, and preferably overnight. The next day, smoke the pigeons at 250 F for 2 hours, then cool and reserve.

Beans

Bring the beans, onion, garlic, and bay leaf to a boil, then turn the heat to a simmer and cook for 3-4 hours, or until the beans are tender (tepary beans can take twice as long to cook as most beans). Allow the beans to cool in their liquid while you prepare the rest of the ingredients. Reserve the bean cooking liquid just in case the pot threatens to get dry.

Stew

In a dutch oven or similar pot of 3 quart capacity, render the bacon in the fat until lightly browned, then add the small game pieces, moving the bacon to one side of the pan, and brown lightly. Add the onion and garlic to the pan and cook for 5 minutes more. Add the remaining ingredients, including the cooked beans, bring to a simmer, cover, leaving the lid ajar, and simmer for 2 hours, or until the meat moves freely from the bones. Cool the stew until you can handle the meat.
Pick the meat from the bones, discarding the pigeon skin and bones from the small game, then add back to the pot, double check the seasoning for salt and pepper, adjust as needed, adding some of the reserved bean liquid if the liquid gets low, and serve with a good slice of crusty bread.

Eating Unborn Venison: an Unusual Product of Deer Culls